Ages 5-12 · Book 5, Empathy · 4,299 places
Noticing When Someone Is Struggling
Empathy as an attention skill first and a feeling second, which is the order that can actually be practised.
Built on Ellis Abel and the Helping Hand — “What matters more than earning a Gold Star?” A character series, not a curriculum with a worldview attached.
The five sessions
- Session 1
Read the story and stop at the moment Maya's work is ruined
- Session 2
Ask what Ellis Abel stood to lose by helping
- Session 3
Name the harder thing: telling the truth about a mistake
- Session 4
Each child names one person they will notice this week
- Session 5
Follow up by name and ask what they noticed
Questions leaders ask
Is noticing when someone is struggling in your area a religious program?
No. Ellis Abel is a character series. Each volume carries one named core value — this one is empathy — and the story does the teaching. There is no doctrine in it, nothing to opt out of, and it is used in public schools, libraries and secular programs as readily as anywhere else.
What ages does this work for?
Ages 5-12. The story is read aloud, so a child who cannot read yet is fully in it, and the discussion prompts are written in two bands so one adult can hold a mixed-age room.
We have tried things like this in your area before and stopped. Why is this different?
Because it is ten minutes and it survives a missed night. There is no streak to break and nothing to catch up on — you pick up at the next chapter.
What if my child will not talk about it?
Then read it anyway and say nothing. Children answer days later, in the car, about something else entirely. The prompts are there when they are ready, not a toll you have to pay to finish the book.
The rules that make it work
Helping has to cost something
Kindness that is free teaches nothing, and children over about eight already know it. The cost is named out loud in every session.
Notice first — it is an attention skill
Empathy gets taught as a feeling children are supposed to summon. It starts as noticing one specific person, which is trainable and testable.
Owning a mistake is the harder lesson
Helping a friend is easier than admitting you were the one who caused the problem. The book teaches both, and this is the one adults skip.
Do not announce it
The moment helping becomes a thing you are seen doing, it becomes a performance. The follow-up asks what changed for the other person, never how the helper felt.
Success is bigger than the award
The gold star is in the title for a reason. A room that only celebrates outcomes has already taught the lesson this book is arguing with.
Adults go first, with a real mistake
An adult naming something they got wrong, at a cost, changes a room faster than any activity in it.
Noticing Others by metro area
Northeast
- Noticing Others — New York, NY
- Noticing Others — Philadelphia, PA
- Noticing Others — Boston, MA
- Noticing Others — Pittsburgh, PA
- Noticing Others — Providence, RI
- Noticing Others — Hartford, CT
- Noticing Others — Buffalo, NY
- Noticing Others — Rochester, NY
- Noticing Others — Bridgeport, CT
- Noticing Others — Albany, NY
- Noticing Others — Worcester, MA
- Noticing Others — Allentown, PA
- Noticing Others — Poughkeepsie metro area, NY
- Noticing Others — Syracuse, NY
- Noticing Others — Harrisburg, PA
- Noticing Others — New Haven, CT
- Noticing Others — Portland, ME
- Noticing Others — Scranton, PA
- Noticing Others — Lancaster, PA
- Noticing Others — York, PA
- Noticing Others — Springfield, MA
- Noticing Others — Waterbury, CT
- Noticing Others — Reading, PA
- Noticing Others — Manchester, NH
- Noticing Others — Trenton, NJ
- Noticing Others — Atlantic City, NJ
- Noticing Others — Utica, NY
- Noticing Others — Norwich, CT
- Noticing Others — Erie, PA
- Noticing Others — Binghamton, NY
- Noticing Others — Barnstable, MA
- Noticing Others — Burlington, VT
- Noticing Others — Kingston, NY
- Noticing Others — Amherst, MA
- Noticing Others — Chambersburg, PA
- Noticing Others — Bangor, ME
- Noticing Others — State College, PA
- Noticing Others — Vineland, NJ
- Noticing Others — Lebanon, PA
- Noticing Others — Johnstown, PA
- Noticing Others — Pittsfield, MA
- Noticing Others — Glens Falls, NY
- Noticing Others — Altoona, PA
- Noticing Others — Lewiston, ME
- Noticing Others — Williamsport, PA
- Noticing Others — Watertown, NY
- Noticing Others — Gettysburg, PA
- Noticing Others — Ithaca, NY
- Noticing Others — Elmira, NY
Midwest
- Noticing Others — Chicago, IL
- Noticing Others — Detroit, MI
- Noticing Others — Minneapolis, MN
- Noticing Others — St. Louis, MO
- Noticing Others — Cincinnati, OH
- Noticing Others — Kansas City, MO
- Noticing Others — Columbus, OH
- Noticing Others — Indianapolis, IN
- Noticing Others — Cleveland, OH
- Noticing Others — Milwaukee, WI
- Noticing Others — Grand Rapids, MI
- Noticing Others — Omaha, NE
- Noticing Others — Dayton, OH
- Noticing Others — Des Moines, IA
- Noticing Others — Madison, WI
- Noticing Others — Akron, OH
- Noticing Others — Wichita, KS
- Noticing Others — Toledo, OH
- Noticing Others — Springfield, MO
- Noticing Others — Lansing, MI
- Noticing Others — Fort Wayne, IN
- Noticing Others — Youngstown, OH
- Noticing Others — Flint, MI
- Noticing Others — Canton, OH
- Noticing Others — Davenport, IA
- Noticing Others — Ann Arbor, MI
- Noticing Others — Peoria, IL
- Noticing Others — Lincoln, NE
- Noticing Others — Rockford, IL
- Noticing Others — Green Bay, WI
- Noticing Others — South Bend, IN
- Noticing Others — Sioux Falls, SD
- Noticing Others — Duluth, MN
- Noticing Others — Cedar Rapids, IA
- Noticing Others — Evansville, IN
- Noticing Others — Fargo, ND
- Noticing Others — Kalamazoo, MI
- Noticing Others — Appleton, WI
- Noticing Others — Champaign, IL
- Noticing Others — Topeka, KS
- Noticing Others — Rochester, MN
- Noticing Others — Lafayette, IN
- Noticing Others — Columbia, MO
- Noticing Others — Joplin, MO
- Noticing Others — Elkhart, IN
- Noticing Others — Springfield, IL
- Noticing Others — St. Cloud, MN
- Noticing Others — Racine, WI
- Noticing Others — Saginaw, MI
- Noticing Others — Iowa City, IA
- Noticing Others — Muskegon, MI
- Noticing Others — Eau Claire, WI
- Noticing Others — Oshkosh, WI
- Noticing Others — Bloomington, IL
- Noticing Others — La Crosse, WI
- Noticing Others — Terre Haute, IN
- Noticing Others — Waterloo, IA
- Noticing Others — Kenosha, WI
- Noticing Others — Janesville, WI
- Noticing Others — Bloomington, IN
- Noticing Others — Jackson, MI
- Noticing Others — Traverse City, MI
- Noticing Others — Rapid City, SD
- Noticing Others — Monroe, MI
- Noticing Others — Jefferson City, MO
- Noticing Others — Niles, MI
- Noticing Others — Sioux City, IA
- Noticing Others — Bismarck, ND
- Noticing Others — Wausau, WI
- Noticing Others — Manhattan, KS
- Noticing Others — Springfield, OH
- Noticing Others — Battle Creek, MI
- Noticing Others — Ames, IA
- Noticing Others — Mansfield, OH
- Noticing Others — Lawrence, KS
- Noticing Others — St. Joseph, MO
- Noticing Others — Sheboygan, WI
- Noticing Others — Muncie, IN
- Noticing Others — Sandusky, OH
- Noticing Others — Michigan City, IN
- Noticing Others — Kankakee, IL
- Noticing Others — Grand Forks, ND
- Noticing Others — Mankato, MN
- Noticing Others — Fond du Lac, WI
- Noticing Others — Bay City, MI
- Noticing Others — Lima, OH
- Noticing Others — Dubuque, IA
- Noticing Others — Decatur, IL
- Noticing Others — Cape Girardeau, MO
- Noticing Others — Columbus, IN
- Noticing Others — Kokomo, IN
- Noticing Others — Midland, MI
- Noticing Others — Grand Island, NE
- Noticing Others — Minot, ND
South
- Noticing Others — Dallas, TX
- Noticing Others — Houston, TX
- Noticing Others — Atlanta, GA
- Noticing Others — Washington, DC
- Noticing Others — Miami, FL
- Noticing Others — Tampa, FL
- Noticing Others — Orlando, FL
- Noticing Others — Charlotte, NC
- Noticing Others — Baltimore, MD
- Noticing Others — San Antonio, TX
- Noticing Others — Austin, TX
- Noticing Others — Nashville, TN
- Noticing Others — Virginia Beach, VA
- Noticing Others — Jacksonville, FL
- Noticing Others — Raleigh, NC
- Noticing Others — Oklahoma City, OK
- Noticing Others — Louisville, KY
- Noticing Others — Richmond, VA
- Noticing Others — Memphis, TN
- Noticing Others — Birmingham, AL
- Noticing Others — Tulsa, OK
- Noticing Others — Greenville, SC
- Noticing Others — New Orleans, LA
- Noticing Others — Knoxville, TN
- Noticing Others — Sarasota metro area, FL
- Noticing Others — McAllen, TX
- Noticing Others — Charleston, SC
- Noticing Others — Baton Rouge, LA
- Noticing Others — El Paso, TX
- Noticing Others — Columbia, SC
- Noticing Others — Cape Coral, FL
- Noticing Others — Lakeland, FL
- Noticing Others — Greensboro, NC
- Noticing Others — Little Rock, AR
- Noticing Others — Deltona, FL
- Noticing Others — Winston-Salem, NC
- Noticing Others — Palm Bay, FL
- Noticing Others — Augusta, GA
- Noticing Others — Durham, NC
- Noticing Others — Fayetteville, AR
- Noticing Others — Jackson, MS
- Noticing Others — Chattanooga, TN
- Noticing Others — Port St. Lucie, FL
- Noticing Others — Huntsville, AL
- Noticing Others — Pensacola, FL
- Noticing Others — Lexington, KY
- Noticing Others — Killeen, TX
- Noticing Others — Wilmington, NC
- Noticing Others — Corpus Christi, TX
- Noticing Others — Ocala, FL
- Noticing Others — Savannah, GA
- Noticing Others — Brownsville, TX
- Noticing Others — Gulfport, MS
- Noticing Others — Myrtle Beach, SC
- Noticing Others — Lafayette, LA
- Noticing Others — Asheville, NC
- Noticing Others — Naples, FL
- Noticing Others — Mobile, AL
- Noticing Others — Spartanburg, SC
- Noticing Others — Beaumont, TX
- Noticing Others — Tallahassee, FL
- Noticing Others — Fayetteville, NC
- Noticing Others — Montgomery, AL
- Noticing Others — Shreveport, LA
- Noticing Others — Hickory, NC
- Noticing Others — Lubbock, TX
- Noticing Others — Huntington, WV
- Noticing Others — Gainesville, FL
- Noticing Others — Clarksville, TN
- Noticing Others — Columbus, GA
- Noticing Others — Roanoke, VA
- Noticing Others — Hagerstown, MD
- Noticing Others — Fort Walton Beach metro area, FL
- Noticing Others — Kingsport, TN
- Noticing Others — Waco, TX
- Noticing Others — Longview, TX
- Noticing Others — College Station, TX
- Noticing Others — Tuscaloosa, AL
- Noticing Others — Laredo, TX
- Noticing Others — Slidell, LA
- Noticing Others — Amarillo, TX
- Noticing Others — Lynchburg, VA
- Noticing Others — Daphne, AL
- Noticing Others — Tyler, TX
- Noticing Others — Lake Charles, LA
- Noticing Others — Hilton Head Island, SC
- Noticing Others — Macon, GA
- Noticing Others — Fort Smith, AR
- Noticing Others — Panama City, FL
- Noticing Others — Charlottesville, VA
- Noticing Others — Gainesville, GA
- Noticing Others — Athens, GA
- Noticing Others — Monroe, LA
- Noticing Others — Punta Gorda, FL
- Noticing Others — Jacksonville, NC
- Noticing Others — Johnson City, TN
- Noticing Others — Lexington Park, MD
- Noticing Others — Warner Robins, GA
- Noticing Others — Auburn, AL
- Noticing Others — Florence, SC
- Noticing Others — Charleston, WV
- Noticing Others — Houma, LA
- Noticing Others — Bowling Green, KY
- Noticing Others — Dover, DE
- Noticing Others — Midland, TX
- Noticing Others — Burlington, NC
- Noticing Others — Abilene, TX
- Noticing Others — Jackson, TN
- Noticing Others — Greenville, NC
- Noticing Others — Blacksburg, VA
- Noticing Others — Odessa, TX
- Noticing Others — Vero Beach metro area, FL
- Noticing Others — Homosassa Springs, FL
- Noticing Others — Decatur, AL
- Noticing Others — Hattiesburg, MS
- Noticing Others — The Villages metro area, FL
- Noticing Others — Florence, AL
- Noticing Others — Dothan, AL
- Noticing Others — Sherman, TX
- Noticing Others — Valdosta, GA
- Noticing Others — Winchester, VA
- Noticing Others — Wichita Falls, TX
- Noticing Others — Rocky Mount, NC
- Noticing Others — Alexandria, LA
- Noticing Others — Dalton, GA
- Noticing Others — Texarkana, TX
- Noticing Others — Albany, GA
- Noticing Others — Morgantown, WV
- Noticing Others — Hammond, LA
- Noticing Others — Harrisonburg, VA
- Noticing Others — Jonesboro, AR
- Noticing Others — Wheeling, WV
- Noticing Others — Cleveland, TN
- Noticing Others — Salisbury, MD
- Noticing Others — Staunton, VA
- Noticing Others — Morristown, TN
- Noticing Others — Elizabethtown, KY
- Noticing Others — Lawton, OK
- Noticing Others — Goldsboro, NC
- Noticing Others — San Angelo, TX
- Noticing Others — Brunswick, GA
- Noticing Others — Anniston, AL
- Noticing Others — Owensboro, KY
- Noticing Others — Steubenville, WV
- Noticing Others — Sebring, FL
- Noticing Others — Pinehurst, NC
- Noticing Others — Beckley, WV
- Noticing Others — Sumter, SC
- Noticing Others — Gadsden, AL
- Noticing Others — Paducah, KY
- Noticing Others — Rome, GA
- Noticing Others — Victoria, TX
- Noticing Others — Hot Springs, AR
- Noticing Others — Hinesville, GA
- Noticing Others — Parkersburg, WV
- Noticing Others — Enid, OK
- Noticing Others — Eagle Pass, TX
West
- Noticing Others — Los Angeles, CA
- Noticing Others — Phoenix, AZ
- Noticing Others — Riverside, CA
- Noticing Others — San Francisco, CA
- Noticing Others — Seattle, WA
- Noticing Others — San Diego, CA
- Noticing Others — Denver, CO
- Noticing Others — Portland, OR
- Noticing Others — Sacramento, CA
- Noticing Others — Las Vegas, NV
- Noticing Others — San Jose, CA
- Noticing Others — Salt Lake City, UT
- Noticing Others — Fresno, CA
- Noticing Others — Tucson, AZ
- Noticing Others — Honolulu, HI
- Noticing Others — Bakersfield, CA
- Noticing Others — Albuquerque, NM
- Noticing Others — Boise, ID
- Noticing Others — Oxnard, CA
- Noticing Others — Stockton, CA
- Noticing Others — Colorado Springs, CO
- Noticing Others — Provo, UT
- Noticing Others — Ogden, UT
- Noticing Others — Spokane, WA
- Noticing Others — Reno, NV
- Noticing Others — Modesto, CA
- Noticing Others — Santa Rosa, CA
- Noticing Others — Visalia, CA
- Noticing Others — Vallejo, CA
- Noticing Others — Salem, OR
- Noticing Others — Santa Maria, CA
- Noticing Others — Salinas, CA
- Noticing Others — Anchorage, AK
- Noticing Others — Eugene, OR
- Noticing Others — Greeley, CO
- Noticing Others — Fort Collins, CO
- Noticing Others — Boulder, CO
- Noticing Others — Kennewick, WA
- Noticing Others — Olympia, WA
- Noticing Others — Merced, CA
- Noticing Others — Bremerton, WA
- Noticing Others — San Luis Obispo, CA
- Noticing Others — Bend, OR
- Noticing Others — Yakima, WA
- Noticing Others — Santa Cruz, CA
- Noticing Others — Prescott metro area, AZ
- Noticing Others — Bellingham, WA
- Noticing Others — Las Cruces, NM
- Noticing Others — Lake Havasu City, AZ
- Noticing Others — Yuma, AZ
- Noticing Others — Medford, OR
- Noticing Others — St. George, UT
- Noticing Others — Chico, CA
- Noticing Others — Billings, MT
- Noticing Others — Coeur d'Alene, ID
- Noticing Others — Yuba City, CA
- Noticing Others — Redding, CA
- Noticing Others — El Centro, CA
- Noticing Others — Idaho Falls, ID
- Noticing Others — Pueblo, CO
- Noticing Others — Grand Junction, CO
- Noticing Others — Logan, UT
- Noticing Others — Maui, HI
- Noticing Others — Santa Fe, NM
- Noticing Others — Hanford, CA
- Noticing Others — Flagstaff, AZ
- Noticing Others — Mount Vernon, WA
- Noticing Others — Napa, CA
- Noticing Others — Albany, OR
- Noticing Others — Bozeman, MT
- Noticing Others — Missoula, MT
- Noticing Others — Wenatchee, WA
- Noticing Others — Sierra Vista, AZ
- Noticing Others — Twin Falls, ID
- Noticing Others — Farmington, NM
- Noticing Others — Longview, WA
- Noticing Others — Cheyenne, WY
- Noticing Others — Corvallis, OR
- Noticing Others — Helena, MT
- Noticing Others — Fairbanks, AK
- Noticing Others — Pocatello, ID
- Noticing Others — Grants Pass, OR
- Noticing Others — Great Falls, MT
- Noticing Others — Casper, WY
- Noticing Others — Lewiston, ID
- Noticing Others — Walla Walla, WA
- Noticing Others — Carson City, NV
Cities and all 3,143 US counties are covered too — every place page is live. The campaign sitemap lists every one.